Mullings of a Retired Lawyer-Duties and Ethics This Time

Charles G. Stephenson Frame

Presented October 8, 2024

1. Introduction

I practiced law for fifty-seven years. It was a rewarding experience, intellectually stimulating and satisfying. I took a chance selecting this line of work since when I’d gone to law school I knew nothing about what it would all be about. It worked out. I was lucky. I loved being a lawyer. But, after I retired, I discovered that I didn’t miss the practice. That seemed strange after so many years doing it, 57 and change. I mulled this over which is what Stephensons do when they ponder. Mulling told me that what I didn’t miss was the stress of the practice. Mulling also told me that the reason for the stress that I didn’t miss was the continual need to comply with the rules of professional responsibility imposed on lawyers.

Lawyers have duties of loyalty to their clients, loyalty, confidentiality and care. They must be honest and ethical. They must comply with all laws governing their conduct, not only in their practice but in their individual lives. And they must obey all rules of ethical conduct and professional responsibility. This is a lot. I didn’t realize until after I retired how much pressure all this stuff caused.

When I went to law school there were no courses on what exactly our duties and professional responsibilities would be once we became lawyers. Not only no courses, not even much discussion that I remember. We learned and analyzed some of the laws, critically and in depth, mostly by reading ultimate appellate court decisions in case after case after case, followed by not-so-fun Socratic discussions of the cases with our professors.

In the old days, before there were many law schools, many of the budding lawyers learned their trade in a lawyer’s office, observing and listening and helping out. These guys were luckier than those who attended law schools because they were learning how to be lawyers and what rules and standards they’d be held to in practice. Law schools must have expected that if we were smart enough to get in and stay in, we must be savvy enough to know what would be expected of us duty-wise and ethics-wise and to know what’s right and what’s wrong in the process of doing whatever it was we would be doing. Wrong.

I had to learn most of these rules while I was working, after I’d passed the Bar Exam, often as I encountered them, sometimes from mentors, sometimes from colleagues, and sometimes from reading. I also learned to rely on my innate sense of logic and of what’s right and what’s wrong. To my knowledge I only made a couple of mistakes that I couldn’t correct. I was lucky enough to have grown up with a principled father who lectured me every night at the dinner table on what that day he thought I’d done right and what that day he thought I’d done wrong, mostly the latter. He didn’t look at my brother while lecturing, only at me.

Not until later, well after I became a lawyer, did law schools and the State Bar figure that maybe not enough had been done in these areas, that maybe we did need some guidance, that maybe they should have courses on legal ethics and professional responsibilities. Now, these areas are taught in law schools, and last I heard there is at least one section in the California State Bar Exam on these topics..

Here is a summary of some of my thoughts on this subject, the fruits of my mulling. It’s not a definitive lesson on lawyers’ duties and responsibilities. It’s only something put together during retirement while mulling, A lawyer’s overriding responsibility is to be honest, not only in his practice but in his life, and to comply with laws and duties governing his life and his practice.

The primary duties a lawyer owes a client are loyalty, confidentiality and care.

The duty of loyalty means an undivided loyalty to the client. Can’t have any loyalty to someone else on the subject matter that might conflict with it. Can’t do anything adverse to the client. Can’t even be perceived as having a duty of loyalty to someone else that may put you in the position of not being completely loyal to your client. If you do it’s called a conflict of interest, and a conflict must be avoided. Do not represent another person in a transaction in which your client is involved if in helping one, you could hurt the other.

The duty of confidentiality requires that all communications between lawyer and client not be disclosed by the lawyer to anyone else. This means communications both ways, what the lawyer has said to his client and what the client has said to his lawyer. Clients can do as they wish with these communications. They can disclose them, if they wish, to anyone. On the other hand, they do not have to disclose them if they don’t want to unless a court orders them to do so.

The duty of care, which to me is the granddaddy of the duties, is the one that’s the most stressful, it’s the one that requires the lawyer to know the laws involved in the matter on which he is working for his client and to apply those laws correctly, the same as would be done by similarly situated lawyers. If he is an expert in the applicable area he will be held to a higher standard of care, the level of the experts.

Lawyers must obey other rules, those that are imposed by custom or by the laws of the State in which they are licensed to practice. For example, the California Probate Code requires Court approval of any fee to be paid to a lawyer for his service to the executor in a probate. A lawyer who gets paid before the Court says what he can get can be reported by the Judge to the State Bar Ethics Committee.

In California, most of the duties are set forth in the Rules of Professional Responsibility for California lawyers’ sections of the Business and Professions Code, one amongst many California Codes. Bar Associations, such as the California State Bar and the American Bar Association, have their own sets of written rules of professional responsibility, not too much different from the States’ rules.

If we don’t live up to the rules or fall short of one of our duties, we risk malpractice liability to a client who’s been harmed by our breach or lapse. We can also be publicly reproved or worse yet, disbarred by the State Bar for violating our duties. Lawyers can also be disbarred if they’re convicted of a felony, especially one that involves moral turpitude. Lawyers can be disbarred if they go to prison for not paying taxes.

Many lawyers who have lost their licenses to practice have done so for filching their clients’ money. Lawyers often ask clients for retainers before they start working on a matter. It’s wise to do so in some instances. Settlement or judicial awards are often paid to the prevailing client’s lawyer who then divides it between the client and himself according to their contract. There are laws governing the lawyer’s handling of these monies. The lawyer must deposit retainers and the settlement or judicial awards, so-called client monies, in a separate interest-bearing account. It’s called a clients’ trust account. Monies can only be withdrawn from the trust account for payment of bills for work done for that client or for turning over to a client. If there is a balance remaining at the end of a case or the project, the unused balance must be returned to the client, together with the interest earned on it, or if the client cannot be found, the remaining money must be paid to the State. The lawyer cannot keep the unearned balance. Sadly, there are lawyers who pay themselves more than their agreed upon fees from the trust account. They’re the ones who get disbarred.

Lawyers owe duties of honesty and probity to the courts and their fellow lawyers. Lawyers are officers of the Court.

Just about all rules governing a lawyer’s conduct make sense. We should be able to figure when we’re getting into an ethics or duty situation. Common sense helps a lot. Even though the rules make sense, they are not always easy to comply with in real life situations.

Very early in my career, about a year and a half in, I learned an ethics lesson the hard way. I was an associate lawyer in a 35-lawyer firm, which at that time was one of the larger firms in San Francisco. The firm let its lawyers take on any sort of case we could find. It was a good way for us to learn to be lawyers. I brought in a client who found himself at odds with three other guys. I forget the specifics. In doing my diligence, I figured I could learn more about what the beef was about by phoning up one of the guys on the other side. I didn’t know, but I should have been able to figure it out, that a lawyer cannot talk to an opposing party who has his own lawyer without his lawyer being present. That’s so the lawyer, by objecting, can keep his client from divulging information that his lawyer thinks should be kept under wraps at least until the lawyer thinks it’s the right time to do so or until a court orders that it be divulged. The next thing I remember after phoning one of the guys on the other side is being visited in my tiny associate’s office by three grizzled middle-aged lawyers, two. They represented the three guys my client was at odds with, one of whom I’d phoned for information. They were upset that I’d talked to one of their clients without their knowledge and consent which they probably wouldn’t have given. I immediately sensed they were right and I was wrong. They gave me a lecture on my ethical responsibilities. I was scared [expletive] and was chastened. They never told my senior partners or the court or the State Bar. They were gentlemen, and I was grateful. I’d dodged a bullet and learned a legal ethics lesson in the process.

My error put me on permanent high alert. Never again.

A few years after my “phoning the guy on the other side” mistake, I was involved in a case regarding who was entitled to the eminent domain award when the City and County of San Francisco was taking our client’s residential hotel in order to expand the Embarcadero. The owner of the property, our client, or the tenant who was running the property, the guy on the other side. We believed that the answer depended on the terms of the lease which said that if the property was condemned, the condemnation award should be paid to the owner, our client. The tenant claimed that the lease should not apply on some equitable type of argument, like that’s not what the deal really was. We took the deposition of the tenant, the guy on the other side. One of the senior litigation partners in my firm handled it. I was his assistant in this case. About two hours into the deposition, I heard my partner ask the tenant what he had told his lawyer about the lease negotiations with my client and what his lawyer had then told him. The tenant answered these questions. I thought back to my case when I was a fledgling lawyer phoning the guy on the other side and being given a lesson in ethics by his lawyer. The tenant’s lawyer did not object. He should have. I was surprised. I looked at his lawyer. He was asleep. My partner had seen it and was taking advantage of the situation. My partner could ask any question he wanted because the other guy was in the presence of his lawyer. It was up to his lawyer to stay awake so he could hear the questions and object to those he thought were improper, which these were. We won the case on a Summary Judgment motion without even having to proceed to trial. We used the deposition testimony we had gleaned from the tenant while his lawyer was sleeping. The tenant’s lawyer had violated his duty of care by sleeping during parts of his client’s deposition and rendering himself unable to decide whether a question was improper and object. The questions were improper as they intruded on matters protected by the attorney client privilege. But the questions were asked in the presence of the guy’s lawyer. His lawyer should have objected and prevented his client from answering. But he didn’t because he was asleep. The sleeping lawyer could, and should, have been sued by his client for malpractice.

1. Duty of Loyalty

I’ve said a bit about the duty of loyalty already. Remember what I said, undivided loyalty to just your client, no one else, no conflicts, not even a perceived conflict.

Suppose I represent a single parent. He asks me to draft a trust for his spendthrift son so he can control the son’s spending. Can’t do it unless the son, who will become my client, consents to waive any claim of conflict of interest that I have with his father. Otherwise, the son has to get his own lawyer who may advise him not to go along with what Dad wants. Maybe negotiate some type of arrangement that satisfies both of them, father and son.

Suppose a client wants to make a gift or bequest to me, her lawyer. I have a conflict of interest on this. Duty of loyalty to my client not to let her be taken advantage of by me, the lawyer she trusts, and loyalty to myself who’s just been offered an enrichment. I must tell my client that I can’t accept a gift or bequest. If she persists, I can refer her to another lawyer of her own choice who can prepare the document making this gift or bequest if she still wants to do it after hearing some reasons why she shouldn’t do it.

Suppose that you are all finished working on a matter with a client. Then, you are approached by someone else whose new matter is potentially adverse to your former client. Can you take the case? How much time should elapse before you can take one of these on? The longer the better. If the later client’s case involves something about your former client that involves information you learned while representing him that could be used against him, don’t take the later case, no matter when. When in doubt you could ask the former client for his consent to represent the later client. Sometimes the former client will say “yes,” he’ll waive the conflict. Sometimes he won’t.

Suppose you represent two or more persons on a particular matter. Make sure they have no conflict in the matter, some aspect where their interests may diverge. A conflict of interest may prevent you from complying with your undivided duty of loyalty to each one of them. If you proceed on the case without getting waivers of conflict from both of them and if the case goes bad for one of them, you’ll be reminded of this conflict by a plaintiffs’ malpractice lawyer staring you down after filing his Complaint in Court against you. He represents one of your former clients, the one who thinks the multiple representation prevented you from achieving all that he now thinks he should have gotten in the matter, and it’s the reason he lost his case, or the one who doesn’t like the bill you sent him for the services. A conflict of interest prevents you from fulfilling your duty of undivided loyalty to each one of your clients. When you represent two people in one particular transaction, try as you might, it’s difficult or even impossible to fulfill your duty of undivided loyalty to either one when you represent the other.

I spent most of my career as a trusts and estates lawyer, helping people with their estate planning. In many instances I represented married couples. Married couples are built in conflict-of-interest representations. If your clients disagree on any aspect of the estate plan, you can’t take either side, if you do, you’ve not fulfilled your duty of loyalty to the other of them.

In most of my married couple situations there wasn’t a conflict. They’d been happily married for years. It was their first marriage. Thay had the same children. It was easier and cheaper for the two of them to use the same lawyer to do their wills or a trust. In most cases, they’re right. No conflict arises. But not always. One fly that can spoil the ointment is the comingling of community property with separate property. Any money or other property earned by a married person from his labors while living in California is community property. Community property belongs to both spouses in equal shares. Property which is owned by a person before marriage as well as property which is acquired by him or her during marriage from inheritance or gift is his or her separate property. Separate property is owned 100% by the spouse who owns it. If community property and separate property are commingled, the resulting mushed together property is presumed to be community property until it is separated with the help of a forensic accountant. When you represent both spouses, you can’t be the one to sort it out. You’ll always be perceived as favoring the one who got the better deal.

Let’s look at a couple of instances. Your new married clients tell you that they bought their home for $1M in 1985. To pay the purchase price they used $400K of wife’s separate property for the initial payment and $600K from a bank loan secured by a deed of trust or mortgage on the property. From then on, they made the mortgage payments from husband’s salary. The whole time they were residents of California. Still are. In California, earnings from work are community property. The home has increased in value from $1M to $3M. Part of each mortgage payment went towards interest being charged on the loan, the rest as a paydown on the principal. You tell your clients that maybe X% of the home is wife’s separate property, all hers, and maybe Y% is community property, owned half and half by the two of them. You have to use letters (X and Y), not numbers, because you have no clue what the X amount is and none as well as to what the Y amount is. If you try to figure it out by yourself, after much pleading from your penurious clients to do so, you might be walking into a malpractice case years later when one of the clients is not satisfied with the share he or she got when you helped them segregate the ownership. You had a conflict of interest, meaning you cannot go to bat for either one of them if it would be averse to the other client. Can’t be done. If it has to be resolved now, each of them should get a new lawyer and figure it out after paying a lot of money and doing a lot of yelling at each other.

Another example. Suppose the husband is one of the owners of a family farm and during his marriage he works on the farm’s business and due to his efforts, the farm becomes more valuable. He’s not paid enough for the work he’s doing. Why should he, he thinks. More salary would be more income on which he will be taxed. Just let the farm business grow. The farm’s value increase will not be taxed unless he sells it and he doesn’t intend to do that. You hear this story in your initial meeting with him and his wife. They’re happily married, of course. Since you know community property laws you have to explain to them that maybe part of his share of the family farm is community property, no longer his separate property. He’s been spending community property time during their marriage working on something that’s been increasing in value due to his efforts. There’s case law in California establishing such a right. You’ve suddenly got a conflict of interest that will prevent you from helping either one of them in establishing what part of the husband’s interest in the family farm has become community property in which the wife has an undivided half interest. Possible solution-each of them should get a new lawyer to help them figure it out after paying a lot of money and doing a lot of yelling at each other.

When there’s a co-owned community property-separate property situation, one solution might be to kick the question down the road, so to speak. Complete the estate plan with wills or trusts, but avoid any mention in the documents about who owns what part of which property. Assuming that all the property will pass to the children of their marriage when both have died, the issue never needs to be resolved. This approach won’t have the same smooth sailing if the property ultimately will pass to different sets of children when both are gone. Second marriage situations with lots of stepbrothers and stepsisters. In those situations, it’s better not to delay resolution, but the estate planning lawyer cannot represent either spouse in the resolution. Each should have separate counsel.

Married joint clients might have different ideas about how much they want to pass their assets to various of their children. They might differ in their feelings towards a child and his or her abilities to manage an inheritance. If you draft documents that allow the survivor of your two clients to change things as amongst the children, have you violated a duty of loyalty or of care to the child of the one who is the first of them to die by preparing the first-to-die’s plan that can be changed by the survivor? Maybe so, and the child who later gets removed from inheritance by the surviving parent may be able to sue you for allowing this to happen.

I was asked to represent a custodian for life insurance proceeds he’d received for his children. His wife had been killed in an accident. Their children who were the beneficiaries of the life insurance policy on her life sued him for an accounting of what he’d done with the life insurance proceeds, believing there may have been some misappropriation. I filed a response in court on his behalf telling everyone that his accounting would be forthcoming. I would then file it with the Court with copies being sent to his children’s lawyer. My client, the father, sent me his accounting which I reviewed before filing it with the court. The accounting showed he’d used the life insurance proceeds to purchase an apartment building, with such and such an address. I wanted to be sure about this, so I asked my paralegal to check. She discovered that there was no property with that address on that street. I wrote my client a letter asking for an explanation or correction. He didn’t respond. So, I filed a petition with the court asking for the court to approve my resigning as his lawyer. “A noisy withdrawal” is what it’s called. I couldn’t mention the phony investment of the children’s funds. That would be averse to my client, their thieving father. So, I just said that circumstances had arisen which compelled me to withdraw. The Judge approved my request without asking for any explanation. Lawyers for the children were just as silent. I fulfilled my duty of loyalty to my bad-guy former client by not telling the court or the children’s lawyer my reason for withdrawing. They all knew what the deal was, something wasn’t quite right. I’m sure they pursued it.

2. Duty of Confidentiality

I’ve said a bit about the duty of confidentiality already. Anything a client tells his lawyer and anything the lawyer tells the client about the subject matter of the engagement is privileged both ways. The lawyer can’t disclose any of it to others without the client’s prior consent. The client, on the other hand, can disclose what’s been said if he wants to. He doesn’t have to, though, if he doesn’t want to. The confidentiality privilege promotes full and open discourse which in turn means the lawyer should be able to do a better job for his client.

There are exceptions to the confidentiality rule, but precious few. I represented a hot-headed beneficiary of a trust being administered by his uncle. He came to my office before a hearing and told me that if things didn’t go well, he was going to shoot someone, maybe his uncle, maybe the judge. He opened his briefcase and showed me his pistol. I told him that unless he left his gun in my office while we were at court, I was going to report the matter to the court and the police. There’s an exception to the attorney-client privilege when it involves a threat of a criminal act of violence.

When we represent married couples, the confidentiality rule can’t strictly be obeyed because we’re having a three-way communication instead of the usual two person one. So, we have to qualify the rule of confidentiality. Here’s how we do it. We tell them, “Anything either of you tells me I can’t tell a third party but I’ll have to tell the other one of the two of you. I can’t hold any secrets from either of you because of my undivided duty of loyalty to each of you.” This is how we put it in the first meeting, “Don’t tell me anything you don’t want your spouse to hear, because I will pass it on to her because I have an undivided duty of loyalty to her as well as you.” We repeat it in the engagement letter we send them after the initial meeting which they must sign before we start doing any more of the work.

I lived in fear my whole career that one of my married couple clients would tell me about an affair he was conducting on the side. Probably after the joint meeting, he’d ask me to add a little bequest to Fritzy, his mistress. If I obeyed the rule that I’d recited to them during the first meeting, I’d have to get in touch with his wife immediately and tell her what her faithless husband had just confided to me. The occasion never arose during my years of practice, but I feared it might and I still don’t know how I’d handle it. Should I stick by my guns and blab to the wife, after telling her stricken husband that that’s what I was planning to do. “Sorry Fred. That’s what I warned you guys. I’ll just have to phone Alice and tell her.” Then watch the marriage unravel. Or maybe what I might have done is say. “Fred, I told you guys that there can’t be any secrets as between the three of us. Technically I should phone Alice right now and tell her what you just told me. Well, I’m not going to do so. I will not prepare a will for you that makes a bequest to Fritzy. If you really want such a bequest, you’ll have to go to some other lawyer for your entire estate plan.” The problem with this approach is that Fred has told me something that involves the sanctity of my other client’s marriage. Don’t I have to tell Alice? How saintly must I be?

One fellow lawyer thought he was getting around the dilemma by referring his errant husband client to me to prepare a codicil to his will making a bequest to his mistress. I could do this because I didn’t have a conflict of interest because I’d never represented his wife. On the other hand, my fellow lawyer friend may have violated his duty of loyalty to his wife client by sending his other client, the husband, to a fellow lawyer to screw his wife client by helping his husband client keep a nasty little secret from his wife client, a secret that affected the sanctity of their marriage.

Each year my law firm set aside a weekend for its annual retreat, usually at a resort like Silverado in the Napa Valley or Quail Lodge in the Carmel Valley. I hated these retreats. The lawyers sat in a conference room all day, usually without windows while our wives or husbands were gathered around a swimming pool or taking a scenic tour. We’d discuss planning for the firm for the next five years, which was usually saying the same things as last year which we had not started to implement. Part of the day was set aside for department heads to report on the work his practice area had done in the last year. I’d give the report for my department, the trusts and estates practice group. Partners of lawyers are excepted from the rules of confidentiality. I could tell my partners what my clients had been involved with and what I’d done for them. Then my partners’ lips would be sealed, the same as mine. I could report on some of my real-life scary planning cases or explain in King’s English, how I was saving them taxes. How I was dealing with commingled community property and separate property for married clients who still liked each other. How my bad guy client was trying to unravel my other client’s estate plan. The head of the utilities practice told us about rate increases he’d requested from the public utilities commission on behalf of our public utility client. Not only boring but incomprehensible. Inevitably, my partners would tell me after the meeting that my practice was sure a lot more interesting than any of the others.

3. Duty of Care

Amongst duties to our clients is that of care, meaning we must perform up to the standards for lawyers performing similar tasks. This means we must know what the applicable laws are in the situation we’re working on and do whatever we must do consistent with those laws in accomplishing our client’s intent and purpose. We are bound by the standard of excellence of comparable lawyers in our community. If we attain a higher level of stature, then we’re bound to a higher standard of care, that of the experts.

The trusts and estates area of practice has many potential pitfalls in meeting the duty of care. We must accomplish exactly what our client wants and in the most efficient manner complying with, and not running afoul of, tax, trust, will, property, contract, future interest, partnership and other related laws that may be involved in the situation. We can’t make drafting mistakes, such as misdescribing the property being bequeathed. Or leaving out a bequest. Our client is now dead and can’t help us correct it. We must know the applicable tax laws that will be involved in the planning and not run afoul of these laws.

Early on in my career my law firm was involved in an estate case on behalf of an animal rights organization. A wealthy man had died leaving his entire estate to the “National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or its local chapters or affiliates.” One problem was that there was no National SPCA. Another was what did the “or its local chapters or affiliates” mean? Was this an alternative bequest. I was asked by my firm to give it a research memo on the meaning of the word “or” in this context. The unfortunate law firm that drafted the will was now representing the executor of his estate and had to file a petition in court asking the Court for an interpretation of the bequest their partner had drafted. Notices went out to as many animal organizations as they could find. At least one hundred organizations showed up. The lawyers were assigned numbers which they hung around their necks, covering their neckties. After many weeks of trial, the animal organizations, with the Court’s help, reached a settlement by forming a new animal organization to receive this large bequest. Some of the organizations sued the law firm that had drafted the will for not meeting the standard of care in drafting an effective bequest. I learned from this case to always phone the charity to which my client wanted to leave some money just to make sure I would be correctly naming it.

Until recently the U.S. Estate tax was imposed on most of our clients’ estates. The estate tax is complicated. And it’s a big tax, 40% of the amount of the value of the estate in excess of the amount of the exemption. There are ways in which the tax can be avoided or at least minimized. Lawyers who specialize, as I did, are supposed to know these techniques. Depending on the client’s situation, some techniques might be used and others not used. We must tell our client what’s available and whether we think he should use it or not and why or why not. There were always pros and cons involved. This requires the ability to explain complex tax planning in King’s English.

It’s easy to make a mistake. Throughout my career, I made a few mistakes but was lucky enough to discover and correct all of them before any damage had been done. I asked a friend, someone I’d roomed with in law school, whether he ever made any mistakes. Pete, who’d been a First Lieutenant in the Marines between college and law school, answered without hesitating, “Hell yes. By the numbers.”

Mistakes in our trusts and estates area often can result in large, even huge amounts in damages. One of my colleagues, a fellow member of my study group, failed to include a clause in a will that would permit the beneficiary to disclaim the bequest into a bypass trust for his benefit and thereby adopt an alternative disposition still benefiting the disclaiming beneficiary but avoiding or minimizing estate taxes down the road. He was sued.

An out of State law firm made a mistake while representing a California beneficiary of a large trust being administered by a bank in their State. The Trust would be subject to estate tax in their California client’s estate if he still held a certain power when he died. The trust was scheduled to terminate 30 years later. If he was still living, then the trust would be distributed to him. But if he died in the next 30 years the trust would be subject to estate tax in his estate if he still had that fatal power. The law firm knew all this and they also knew that their California client could renounce the power within 6 months after attaining the age of majority. The age of majority in their state was 21 as it had been in California since the beginning. California changed its age of majority to 18. The law firm didn’t know about this change and the 6-month renunciation period slipped by. If their client died before the trust terminated the trust would incur a 40% estate tax. A huge potential damage. The trustee and the out-of-state law firm should have hired a California lawyer to keep them apprised of California laws that might apply. The California beneficiary sued the trustee and the out-of-State lawyers for malpractice, for violating their duty of care. The potential damages were such that the firm’s malpractice insurer discontinued future affordable coverage. The law firm ended up having to dissolve. No more affordable insurance. Its good lawyers retired earlier than they planned or moved to other firms.

A lawyer friend of mine drafted a revocable living trust for his client, and then helped the client transfer title to her assets from her name to the name of her trust. This is standard estate planning in California It’s a way to avoid a costly probate proceeding at death. Since the client can revoke the trust if she wants, she’s deemed for all U.S. and state tax purposes to own the assets in the trust. Transfers of property to the trust are not gifts nor are they sales. Anyway, my lawyer friend’s client just happened to be English and have property in England. Under the laws of England transfers to any type of trust are deemed to be sales, on which the transferor must pay a U.K. capital gains income tax. This is true even if the trust is revocable. The law doesn’t make sense, but that’s what it is. My lawyer friend made a mistake. Transferring property to the trust was a sale, on which U.K. income taxes were incurred. He should have researched the laws of England since they would be involved. I never found out what he did about it.

I was a partner in a law firm for 25 years. There was a lawyer in the firm who didn’t keep up with changes in the laws. He was a smart man and had done well in law school. The problem was that the laws he knew were 30 years old and may have been changed. Other laws had been enacted during the ensuing thirty years. He was a living working time bomb, all ready to go off, failure to abide by the duty of care. He was a senior partner and couldn’t be easily fired as he should have been. I, being one of the juniors, was assigned the task of supervising his work which he didn’t like.

Because of the number of mistakes that can be made, and were, and the astronomical amounts of potential damages, lawyers in the trusts and estates area are charged the highest amount in premiums for malpractice insurance.

I knew of a tax lawyer from Back East who was a guru in our area nationally. She spoke at National Conferences. She assisted the Internal Revenue Service in writing the Regulations for the generation skipping transfer tax, which is one tax area which is so complicated it’s almost impossible to explain to our clients. Anyway, this lawyer apparently made a mistake on something and ended up committing suicide.

My partner Debbie Kasper and I had a word for the terror felt when it first occurred to us that we might have made a mistake. The word was “clong” and it was usually felt in the middle of the night one second after being jerked awake by the thought of having made a mistake the previous day. Whoever experienced a clong was inevitably the first one to arrive at the office the following morning to review the work and correct it if possible.

4. Duties to courts

Lawyers are officers of the Court. They must not mislead a Court. Court filings must be correct. Facts must be correctly stated. Cases cited must stand for the proposition being claimed.

A lawyer friend told me that his law firm’s client once engaged a New York lawyer who specialized in some relevant area of the law in a case they were working on. The New York lawyer prepared a Brief for them to submit to the Court. My friend’s law firm reviewed the brief and discovered that one of the cases cited did not stand for the proposition being asserted. They asked the New York lawyer to correct the Brief. The New York lawyer refused, so my friend’s law firm withdrew from the case, it had to fire its client.

A lawyer must apprise the court of any changes he wants to make to a court document. In a probate case, when someone has died with a will, the terms of that will must be adopted by the court, the probate court. If the will is confusing or if something’s been left out of the will by mistake, and the estate lawyer wants the court to change the terms of the will to resolve the ambiguity or to add back what’s been left out, the lawyer is duty bound to inform the court and all the beneficiaries of the changes he proposes to make. He does this in the petition he files with the court and which he sends to the beneficiaries. Then, then one or more of the beneficiaries and the court will have an opportunity to weigh in. They might agree or they might not, but it’s all out in the open.

Early in my career, I handled a case in which a lawyer 30 years earlier, before my first birthday, left part of a trust out of his client’s will. His mistake meant that ultimately the trust would be distributed to his client’s sister or her family instead of to his grandchildren. He “corrected” the mistake by adding language to the Court’s order adopting the terms of the trust. He added a survival condition to the sister’s remainder interest, meaning that her children would only get the trust if she survived the life beneficiary. He did this without telling anyone at the time, including the Judge who would be signing this order. His “dead-of-night” correction resulted in changing the beneficial interests 30 years later because the sister didn’t survive the life beneficiary. I represented the family of the sister who’d lost their interest in the trust due to the lawyer’s shenanigans. They’d been harmed by the lawyer who’d made a sneaky correction without telling anyone. As an officer of the court, what the lawyer should have done was file a petition with the court asking for equitable relief, asking for the court to make the correction after notice to the sister who might not agree. Fearing the possibility of failure to get this relief and a resulting malpractice suit by one of the beneficiaries, he’d decided to make a “secret” correction without telling anyone, figuring that he might get away with it.

The aced-out children of the sister hired my law firm when they received a petition from the trustee asking the Court 30 years later to confirm that people other than the aced-out beneficiary’s children were entitled to the trust which was then terminating. My law firm handed the case to me, a fourth-year associate. I won the case in the Probate Court and prevailed again on appeal. The grandchildren appealed to the California Supreme Court which, to my surprise, accepted the case. The Supreme Court reversed the rulings of the lower courts. Its reason-California’s long-standing finality of judgments rule which I was in the process of changing. The “corrected” 1936 order had become final in 1937 even though it had been obtained fraudulently.

Recently, I had lunch with Mike Baker, one of my former partners. Mike, who is 12 years my junior, also recently retired. He just happened to comment that he doesn’t miss the practice because he’s free from its constant stress. I told him that’s the same as I feel. Mike was a trial lawyer his entire career. He said that his clients were always mad. Mad at being sued or mad at having to sue. Lawyers feel their clients’ anger. It’s not fun. Before I could tell him the source of my stress, he named it. “I know the reason for your stress, Charlie. Everything you did involved the chance of a mistake that would cost your client or someone else a large piece of change.”

October 8, 2024