Why are there more redheads in Ireland than in Africa?

Vincent H. Resh, Ph.D. Frame

Presented December 9, 2025

Color is perhaps the most important way that humans can appreciate the world around them— Through color we see the beauty in flowers, sunsets, and autumn leaves. It is also an important way through which humans perceive each other, through the color of our eyes and hair, the color of our clothes, and the color of our skin.

Let’s look at the richness of the different colors of human skin. Skin color was long stereotypically described as being red, white, yellow, or black. These descriptors started in early 18th century Europe. Although long used, these four skin-color designations are very poor descriptors. About 200 years ago, it was clear that a more detailed approach was necessary to describe the many nuances of human skin tones. Today, rather than using a categorical color scheme, science uses descriptions based on reflectometry. With this approach, skin color is measured by the different wavelengths of light that are reflected. Lighter skin reflects more visible wavelengths of light and gives higher values of reflectance than does darker skin.

Nina Jablonsky, formerly of the California Academy of Sciences, interested me in the topic of skin color over 30 years ago. She noted that “We are unified and divided by our skin color. Perhaps no other feature of the human body has more meaning to our lives. Our skin is the meeting place of biology and our everyday experiences. The color of our skin is a product of human evolution that is perceived, experienced and contextualized within the framework of human culture.” Because of the importance of the topic, I often cover the evolution of skin color in lectures at the University of California at Berkeley where I taught over 20,000 undergraduate biology-students.

Human skin-color reflects 5 million years of evolution. Let’s start by asking about how skin color evolved by looking at our closest relatives. These are the primates referred to as pigmy chimpanzees, and they are probably the best example of current descendants of both our and their distant ancestors. And what is the color of their skin? Perhaps picture their faces that are surrounded by black hair? Think of zoo visits or the chimpanzee named J. Fred Muggs appearing on the “Tonight Show”.

Their skin color is white. Although the genetic makeup of pygmy chimps is over 99% like ours, the remaining 1% can represent 3 billion base pairs, which are the building blocks of our genes.

Our early human ancestors split from the common ancestor that we shared with modern-day pygmy chimps about 7 million years ago. The genus Homo that includes us and our ancestors. arose about 2 million years ago. Our species, Homo sapiens, is about 160,000 years old. Given that the earth is about 4.5 billion years old, we’re clearly newcomers!

Until the end of the 20th century, there was still an idea among many scientists that humans evolved from multiple lineages of early humans. This hypothesis suggested that evolution of modern humans occurred independently in in three continents: Africa, Europe, and Asia. However, since the 1980s, work by Allan Wilson and others at Berkeley proposed the “Out of Africa” hypothesis. This states that all humans had their origins in Africa. This idea of a single lineage that we descended from in Africa is the widely accepted explanation today. However, there are many nuances to this idea and it’s not a straightforward line from early African humans that leads to us, the modern humans.

Modern humans are described as being bipedal. This means that we can stand upright on two legs. And, because of our large brains, we are capable of language, symbolic thought, and use of complex tools. Importantly, we are not like the ancestor of both the pygmy chimps and us. They were limited to forested areas to hunt and gather their food. They were restricted to forests because of the inability to regulate their body temperature if they had long exposure to the sun. This is because their bodies were covered with hair. Pigmy chimps have retained that feature today, but we haven’t. Because the chimps couldn’t regulate their body temperatures by sweating, they therefore were confined to forested, shaded areas for much of their activities.

With the rise of bipedalism in humans and our ancestors, along with the potential ability to travel great distances outside of the forest, the ability to regulate and lose body heat became critical. Therefore, cooling by sweating became essential part of human life. However, for evaporative cooling from sweating to occur, the presence of a hairy body is a major problem. The evolutionary loss of a covering of dense body hair enabled our ancestors to move from the forest into the savannah to live and obtain their food for long time periods. This ability expanded their means of survival and increased the number of habitats that they could use.

However, when our ancestors lost the body hair that enabled evaporative cooling to occur, the exposure of skin to high levels of sunlight became a liability. To counter this, a random mutation occurred that led to pigmentation of the skin to protect against solar radiation was advantageous. This protection is caused by a pigment called melanin, which is the pigment that gives fair-skinned people summer tans.

Melanin was a major evolutionary development for the survival of these early humans and eventually us. Genes for melanin production are found in a wide range of organisms, including bacteria, fungi, plants, and many other animals. It serves them in various functions besides ultraviolet light protection, such as defense, thermoregulation, and immune responses.

Dark, melanin skin first appeared in humans about 1.6 million years ago. It was long thought by scientists that melanin evolved in human skin as a way of reducing skin cancer risk from the sun’s ultraviolet rays. There are two types of ultraviolet rays, Ultraviolet A (UV A) and Ultraviolet B (UV B). Both the UV A and UV B rays in sunlight can contribute to skin damage, but they affect the skin very differently. UV A rays penetrate deeper into the skin, causing premature aging and wrinkling. But UV B rays primarily damage the skin’s surface, leading to sunburn and contributing to the development of skin cancer.

There are problems that result from exposure to UV rays in humans. First, UV B damages our DNA. Second, at least since the early 1970s. it has been known that strong sunlight breaks down folic-acid compounds that are a precursor in the pathways needed to replicate our DNA.

Folates are especially important to pregnant females in the embryology and successful development of their fetuses. This is especially important for neural-tube and spinal-cord formation. The extreme case resulting when folates are insufficient is the birth anomaly of spina bifida, where the arches of neural tubes of the spines don’t fold over and close. The need for folates is evident in a 2026 California law requiring that folic-acid supplements be added to commercially produced tortillas because of the higher rate of neural tube defects in Latino communities.

But problems with high ultraviolet exposure are not just confined to women. High exposure to ultraviolet radiation also reduce spermatogenesis, the production of sperm, in males. The presence of melanin in human skin protects against these conditions.

When we were limited to the areas of the world with high ultraviolet radiation, such as in Africa, our species evolved darkly pigmented skin to protect our bodies from the deleterious effects of high levels of ultraviolet radiation. So, the earliest modern humans were living in high UV areas and, consequently, they were also darkly pigmented. While this argument explains why dark-skinned people occur in high ultraviolet light areas of the world, it doesn’t explain why light skim people occur in low ultraviolet regions of the world. This distinction led to further research that identified not only advantages of melanin but potential disadvantages of high levels of melanin in areas far from the equator as well.

The gene associated with dark skin pigmentation (and as I’ll mention later, hair color as well) is the MC1R gene. There is little variation in the genetic material that comprises this gene in the human population in Africa. These variations within a gene are referred to as genetic variants. However, the skin-pigmentation gene of Europeans is associated with a very different genetic variant, one that resulted from a mutation, is very different from those of Africans This variant is not found in Africans. This European genetic variant produces less pigmented and lighter colored skin. Interestingly, there is a different genetic variant that produces lighter skin in east Asians than in either Africans or Europeans. So, a mutation for light skin pigmentation, or depigmentation, occurred at least twice, once in Europe and once in Asia.

Therefore, the original skin of ancient members of our genus Homo was darkly pigmented to protect their bodies from the deleterious effects of ultraviolet radiation. In migrating out of Africa, mutations resulted in genetic variants that produced depigmentation, which is the loss of pigmentation, to occur in humans who migrated from Africa to Europe and Asia.

Why was this shift to lighter skin, i.e. to depigmentation, selected for evolutionarily in certain parts of the world? To understand this, the positive effects of ultraviolet radiation, especially from UV B rays, need to be understood.

The most important of these effects is that UV B rays result in the production of vitamin D in humans. Vitamin D isn’t really a vitamin. It is a hormone that regulates biochemical reactions in our bodies. It enables the body to absorb and use the calcium that is obtained from our food. The biologically active form of vitamin D, which is called calcitriol, increases calcium absorption in our digestive system. Without enough vitamin D, our bodies must depend on the small fraction of the calcium it gets from food. Calcium is necessary for a variety of processes in our bodies that enable us to survive.

Here is how vitamin D works. When ultraviolet radiation penetrates the skin, it interacts with a cholesterol-like molecule to create a compound called pre-vitamin D3. This is done in the presence of UV B, but not UV A radiation. Organs involved in vitamin D production include our skin, liver, and kidneys.

If we have too little vitamin D being produced, there are consequences for every age group. For infants and children, it’s rickets, growth problems, and weakened immunity. Rickets in children results in bowed legs or arms, knock-knees, and soft bones that are prone to fractures. Rickets has reappeared in children in Australia because of the extreme tendency of some parents to cover children with high levels of sunscreen-protective clothing. For adolescents and adults, too little vitamin D results in osteoporosis, bone pain, muscle weakness, and increased risk of fractures.

To evaluate and understand these sometimes-contradictory advantages and disadvantages of skin color, we can consider that humans are on a “knife’s edge” in terms of their skin color and the amount of ultraviolet light that occurs in the environment that they live in. If skin color is too dark in the ultraviolet-radiation environment that they live in, not enough vitamin D is produced. But if skin color is too light in the ultraviolet radiation environment that they live in, DNA damage and folate breakdown result. When this mismatch occurs, all the consequences that I mentioned above can occur. This tradeoff of skin color and environment produced the rainbow of sepia colors that we see today in human skin.

Skin color evolved over the past 60,000 years as humans dispersed out of equatorial Africa into the Eastern Mediterranean region and then as they went on to Europe and Asia. Research has suggested that 10-20,000 years may have been needed for the early human populations to achieve the optimal level of pigmentation in the regions that they migrated to.

Recent research reported in both the scientific literature and popular news outlets have indicated that sunlight has many benefits beyond providing us with vitamin D. For example, it influences several of our genes. These include those that provide some protection against heart disease, cancer, and autoimmune diseases. For example, a study of 360,000 light-skinned people living in Great Britain reported that greater exposure to ultraviolet radiation, such as from living in Britain’s sunnier South than its darker North, correlated with a significantly lower risk of dying, even when skin cancers were considered. A study in Sweden of 30,000 women over a 20-year period found that people with the highest sunlight exposure had a lower risk of dying than people with the lowest exposure to sunlight, again after correcting for health, age and wealth. Finally, a 2017 study found an increase in approximately 5mm of mercury—which are the units that blood pressure is measured– for every 1,000-kilometer increase in distance from the equator, presumably reflecting decreases in sunlight. Finally, it has been speculated that the high rate of teenagers in much of Asia that need reading or distance glasses is related to lack of sunlight exposure, which plays a role in regulating the growth and maturity of children’s eyes. However, all these studies note that both too much and too little sunlight exposure have negative consequences. All still warn of the dangers of sunburn.

When did light-skinned humans first appear? It appears that it occurred somewhere around 8,000-12,000 years ago. When humans migrated out of Africa to areas that had lower ultraviolet radiation, the dark skin that protects against DNA damage, folate damage, and other negative effects was no longer an advantage because of the need for sufficient vitamin D to be produced. In areas with lower ultraviolet radiation, dark skin was a disadvantage. This is because the amount of ultraviolet radiation decreased with northward migration. Consequently, the melanin actually decreased vitamin D production.

The depigmentation genes that produce lighter skin are known from at least 9,000 years ago and were found in human fossils in Anatolia. However, skin color changes also can reflect changes in cultural practices and greatly affected the successful establishment of humans that migrated into new areas. For example, the settlement of Northern Europe couldn’t have originally been possible because insufficient vitamin D was produced in humans for them to be able to live there. This is because not enough solar radiation occurred in these areas. However, as humans learned to capture and eat seal and whale blubber, and fish oils, which are sources of vitamin D from food, these cultural advances enabled settlement of these areas to occur.

So, in summary, in areas of high ultraviolet radiation, such as tropical areas, individuals with darker skin from higher melanin content are better adapted and protected against folate breakdown, reduced sperm production, and the other factors I mentioned. Likewise, individuals with lighter skin are selected for more vitamin D production in lower ultraviolet radiation areas, that is those areas that are greater distances away from the equator.

Now, let me go to the alternate title of my talk: Why Are There More Redheads in Ireland than in Africa? Well, there actually are redheads in Africa. They are found among the indigenous Berbers of North Africa, who sometimes have red hair from specific genetic traits. Some Africans also have a type of albinism, called rufous albinism, that causes them to have red hair. But these are exceptions and in fact are quite rare.

In contrast, Ireland has the highest percentage of redheads in the world, 10% of the total current population and up to 30% in regions where there has been less immigration and mixing. Moreover, 40% of men with beards in Ireland have red-haired beards. Other countries that are close in the proportions of redheads compared to Ireland are Scotland at 6% and England at 4% of their population. But outside Europe only 0.06% of the world’s population has red hair.

Red hair is typically accompanied by fair skin and Ireland has the lightest skin color of any country in the world. As we know, light skin creates conditions to produce Vitamin D that are appropriate for the low-ultraviolet light environment and these are the conditions occur often in much of Ireland.

But the presence of red hair itself also contributes to vitamin D production. Again, consider the climate of Ireland. Overcast skies are far more common than days of sunshine. The red hair and light skin of many of the Irish serves as much of an advantage in that environment just as the dark skin of the Africans in terms of the amounts of solar radiation that they are exposed to. Do you remember the MC1R gene that I mentioned in terms of skin color? That has been identified as one of the genes that is responsible for producing red hair in humans!

In writing this essay, I started to wonder whether people like being redheads because they have such a unique and distinctively different hair color? The internet is full of stories of redheads hating how they were teased or bullied for having red hair. They had nicknames like “carrottop”, “fireball”, or “big red”! I found that this feeling of displeasure about being a redhead was true in talking to people with red hair in both North America and Ireland,

The book “Anne of Green Gables” that is set in Prince Edward Island in the Canadian Maritimes gives a famous description of the problems of having red hair. Many of you probably read this novel as children and it is still assigned in Middle School and High School classes. It has sold over 50 million copies.

Its main character, Anne Shirley, is a redhead. In the novel, she was adopted by a farming couple in Canada but, they wanted and were expecting an orphan boy, not a young girl, to help work on their farm. Anne laments on her having red hair: “Yes, it’s red”, she said resignedly. “Now you see why I can’t be perfectly happy. Nobody could who has red hair. I don’t mind the other things so much – the freckles and the green eyes and my skinniness. I can imagine them away. I can imagine that I have a beautiful rose-leaf complexion and lovely stary violet eyes. But I cannot imagine that red hair away. I do my best. I think to myself, now my hair is a glorious black, black as the raven’s wing. But all the time I know it is just plain red and it breaks my heart. It will be my lifelong sorrow.”

Anecdotally, I’ve found that this opinion is true of most of the people my age (those over 65) that I’ve talked to about their red hair. I think that it’s also true of many of our children’s generation (those over 40). But I don’t think it’s true today for young people. Look at how many of them have chosen to dye their hair red. One woman in her 50’s told me that she hated growing up with red hair but her non-redheaded children all want their children to have red hair!

Let me add one comment about poorly understood advantage of being a natural redhead. Redheads have higher tolerance to certain types of pain than people with other hair colors. This higher tolerance of pain is also linked to a mutation in the MC1R gene, which is the gene that produces red hair but which also affects the balance of pain-regulating hormones in human bodies.

Finally, and returning to the idea of humans being on a “razor’s edge” in terms of skin in terms of the differences in the amount of ultraviolet radiation in the environments that they live in. For example, females worldwide, on average, are about 2% lighter in skin color than males. Is this because men work out-of-doors more? No, because even when exposed to the same amount of sunlight, women are lighter skinned. Is it sexual selection where lighter skin women are preferred and selected evolutionarily to have more light-skin colored offspring? There is not a lot of scientific evidence for this. Or, and this is most perhaps the best explanation, women need more vitamin D to ensure that the fetal bones of their offspring develop successfully. Lighter skin enables higher vitamin D production perhaps to accomplish this? In other words, are the consequences of low vitamin D in pregnant women so negative in terms of their successful reproduction that lighter skin has been evolutionarily selected for in women to complete more successful pregnancies?

Modern migrations of humans are important issues related to skin color and the environments that they live in. Movements over last 4,000 years and especially in last 400 years have resulted in mismatches between amounts of skin pigmentation and the ultraviolet radiation in the environment that people move to and live in. Think of dark-skinned Africans that are now living in gloomy Northern England. Or light skinned Europeans living in equatorial Africa, especially during the colonial period.

Is the skin color of Innuits, also referred to as Eskimos, in the Northern regions of our continent an exception to the patterns observed? Innuits have dark skin, but they live in the high latitudes of the Arctic. What could explain dark skin in the far-north latitudes? Is it the reflection of sunlight on the ice and snow?

Dress matters as well. Lower levels of vitamin D are found in Australians wearing high levels of sun protective, long-sleeved shirts and trousers to protect against sunburns. Likewise, Muslim women wearing full length clothing and hajibs and living in areas with low ultraviolet radiation suffer more from osteoporosis and diseases of weakened bones.

Human origins in Africa and the melanin in our skin reflect that Africa is our ancestral home. My favorite quote about Africa is from John Reader in his 1998 masterpiece Africa: A Biography of the Continent. “Within a span of 4,000 generations…. Humans have dominated the earth and have been to the moon. We see visions of the future in the mind’s eye, and turn them to reality with the aptitudes and talents which evolution bestowed—in Africa.”

Most of the members of our club know from some of my past essays that I spent several months a year in Africa for 15 years. Preparation of this essay reminded me of our African origins. Whenever I returned to Africa, I heard a voice inside me saying “Remember, we are all Africans”. My inner voice then responded with “Welcome Home.”